Yes, but only because they would have had to the confederacy would not have been able to survive as an independent nation-state based on its own resources as an agrarian economy, it had to have access to international markets, particularly for t. As the battle of gettysburg’s 150th anniversary approaches, it’s hard to resist asking, “what if the union had lost that fight, and the south eventually won the war. Southern political forces were behind most of the military adventurism before the civil war - the war of 1812 was specifically pushed by the south, along with the mexican-american war.
The civil-rights revolution, too, can be thought of as a bargain, not simply a victory: the nation has become southernized just as much as the south has become nationalized. How the south lost the war but won the narrative how the south lost the war but won the narrative about 20 percent of white southern males of military age died in the civil war in south. If the south won the civil war other countries if the south had won, england and germany would have had to fight it out to a resource-draining stalemate. By march 1865, it was obvious to all but the most die-hard confederates that the south was going to lose the war whether that loss was inevitable is an unanswerable question, but considering various “what if” scenarios has long been a popular exercise among historians, novelists and civil war buffs.
Fact #6: the north had more men and war materials than the south at the beginning of the civil war, 22 million people lived in the north and 9 million people (4 million of whom were slaves) lived in the south. If the south had won the civil war originally appeared in look magazine nearly half a century ago it immediately inspired a deluge of letters and telegrams from astonished readers, and became an american classic overnight. Civil wars are never easy to win and most often it consumes all energies of both sides it was possible that there could have been stalemate and an official partition the key technology that prevented that from happening and one that ensured a sw.
If the south had won the civil war is a 1961 alternate history book by mackinlay kantor, a writer who also wrote several novels about the american civil war as it actually happened it was originally published in the november 22, 1960, issue of look magazine. Most americans were taught that the north won and the south lost the american civil war but what if the issues that led to the bloodshed were never resolved harvard professor john stauffer connects the civil war era with current events, highlighting how the south effectively won the war and why it matters today. This is the story of how the south could have won the civil war it is based not on fanciful, theoretical conjectures of what might have been but on positive recommendations proposed time after time to the south’s top leaders. The south won the civil war: white men, racial resentment, and how the bitter minority came to rule us all nixon’s silent majority, neither silent nor a majority, runs congress and propels trump.
The northern states won the civil war this article elucidates some of the reasons why the north won and the south lost follow us: who won the civil war the northern states won the civil war this article elucidates some of the reasons why the north won and the south lost. In the beginning of the civil war, the confederacy won many decisive victories as the war continued, however, the confederacy weakened and in the end, the union was the victor. If the south had won the civil war is an early alternate history offering that appeared around the centennial of the start of the civil war kantor tells the story as a historical text, which is interesting. How the south won the civil war by brett stevens on june 25, 2018 most people have trouble separating cause and effect because it requires diligence, analysis, and creativity to understand that a.
By steven jonas, md, mph featured writer dandelion salad crossposted on buzzflashcom august 26, 2009 in his buzzflash editor’s blog of august 15, our editor/publisher mark karlin had this to say about the civil war: “[i]t may have been won by the north, but in truth the south never emotionally conceded. Gettysburg: what if the south had won the war in 1864 is being fought in virginia, said ian isherwood, assistant director of the civil war institute in gettysburg, pa that means the south. The south still lies about the civil war cause version of post-civil war reconstruction in the south still held sway among the vast majority of whites in that state as recently as the early. How the south won the civil war by jim powell posted on june 24, 2008 august 7, 2009 we have been told endlessly that the us civil war was a good war, fought to free the slaves about 110,100 union soldiers were killed in action, and another 224,580 died from war-related diseases an estimated 275,175 union soldiers were wounded.
American civil war alternate histories are alternate history fiction that focuses on the civil war (or a lack thereof) ending differently crosstime traffic series by harry turtledove visits many alternate realities, briefly mentioning a few where the south won the civil war. The us won the civil war the south won the war of history and memory, securing the honor of the cause and forcing reunion on southern white supremacist terms and indeed at a certain, meta. The american civil war was the most devastating event in united states history it changed the entire fate of the nation, and created the america we know today. Conversely, if the civil war ground on indefinitely without a northern victory or if the south managed a decisive battlefield success, perhaps at gettysburg, it could have broken the north’s.